Thursday, May 7, 2009

Pakistan is not a failed state

I.
Amy Goodman and Juan Gonzalez were kind enough to host me this morning on their show, Democracy Now!: Manan Ahmed on the Politics of US “Hysteria” over Pakistan

II.
The excellent UAE National gave me space to develop my argument about the Pakistani "failed state": Legends of the Fail Manan Ahmed examines the decades-old tradition of experts predicting that Pakistan is sure to collapse any day now.

10 comments:

Anonymous said...

Indians, too, are familiar with the "failed state" chorus (as in the "India will break into a zillion pieces" chant). However, in all this mess, what I find deeply disturbing is the fact that the Pakistan army is willing to use heavy artillery against its own citizens in Swat, simply because this way the army keeps its own casualties low. Doesn't this put the Pakistan army on the same level as drone-using Americans? Why can't they fight this insurgency the old fashioned way - i.e. send in the infantry and go from village to village? That way, there might still be human rights violations, but they will be far smaller in scale than this wanton destruction of life and property that is creating such a refugee problem.

Sharmishtha

BENGAL UNDER ATTACK said...

Sharmishtha,

The heavy artillery shows that Pakistan Army is "serious" against the Taliban. And this "show" is for the Americans.

WHY?

The billions of dollars come from there and Pakistan has always acted perfectly whenever its state / country heads visited Washington.

As far as Taliban casualty goes - hardly anything. Civvies - certainly. But billions of dollars over a few hundred deaths - ma'am do you think either the Pakistan Army or the US Centcomm gives a damn !!

Anonymous said...

Reasons for Pakistan's failure:

Political leaders were victimized. Abusive language was used against those who fought for their independence.

"Allama Mashriqi Maliciously Implicated in Murder Case" by Nasim Yousaf

http://www.allamamashraqi.com/grandsonsarticles.html

Unknown said...

I think Pakistan are now getting the failures because of their political approach. It needs to follow the strict action against the offenders will give something better. The US also helps Pakistan to get away from this issue by aiding through money.
hidden object games

Anonymous said...

I think that Pakistan is being damaged because of how their political. Must comply strictly with the offenders to do things better. U.S. to help Pakistan get by this problem by helping over money.

Stardust
BlackBerry Curve
online shopping blog
The Time of My Life

Anonymous said...

It is really interesting to read everything in your post.

Medical Insurance
Medical
Medical Field
Medical

Anonymous said...

failed state.

halloween kids
halloween masks
Sexy Dresses For Halloween
halloween costumes
halloween fun
couples halloween

Anonymous said...

Bridging the gap between generally knowing and really knowing all about boschdishwashers is what this article is about.
Have a question about boschdishwashers? This site/article is all about providing you all the information you've been hunting for.

bathmate said...

As always an excellent posting.The
way you write is awesome.Thanks. Adding more information will be more useful.

Bathmate

pay per head said...

Thanks so much for the post, really effective data.